REPORT OF CONFERENCE COMMITTEE                        # 2

 

MADAM PRESIDENT AND MR. SPEAKER:

 

   We, the undersigned conferees, have had under consideration the amendments to the following entitled BILL:

 

S. B. No. 2760:  Law enforcement officers; provide minimum due process rights for municipal.

 

  We, therefore, respectfully submit the following report and recommendation:

 

  1.  That the House recede from its Amendment No. 1.

 

  2.  That the Senate and House adopt the following amendment:

 

     Amend by striking all after the enacting clause and inserting in lieu thereof the following:

 


     SECTION 1.  This act shall be known and cited as the "Law Enforcement Employment Procedures Act."

     It is the intent of the Legislature to provide a fair and impartial hearing to law enforcement officers employed by municipalities prior to the disciplinary suspension or termination of those officers.

     SECTION 2.  (1)  A municipality shall provide by ordinance orpolicy a pre-disciplinary hearing prior to the suspension or termination of a law enforcement officer employed by the municipality.

     (2)  Nothing in this act shall be construed to prohibit a municipality from placing a law enforcement officer on leave without pay until the entity charged with the responsibility of conducting the hearing has rendered a decision in the matter if the officer has been charged with a criminal offense.  Otherwise, the officer shall be placed on leave with pay pending the decision.  An officer placed on leave without pay who is not found guilty of the criminal offense is eligible for back pay upon reinstatement to duty.

     SECTION 3.  A municipality shall establish written due process procedures applicable to the pre-disciplinary hearing.  At a minimum, this due process shall consist of:

          (a)  Written notice to the officer of the reason or reasons for the termination or suspension.  This notice shall be issued by the person or persons with authority to suspend or terminate the law enforcement officer.  The notice shall also inform the officer that the officer, within five (5) days, may request a hearing in writing and where such written request should be filed.  If the officer fails to request a hearing within five (5) days after receiving written notice of the suspension or termination, the right to such hearing shall be deemed waived.

          (b)  The accused officer shall have the right to appear at the hearing and to be represented at the officer's own expense.  The officer or representative shall have the right to address any charges against the officer.  If the officer has a representative, the officer may also be present at the hearing.

          (c)  The officer or the officer's representative shall have the right to present evidence and question witnesses who testify in the proceeding.

     SECTION 4.  A municipality may also hold a separate post-disciplinary hearing on the suspension or termination of the law enforcement officer.  If the municipality holds a separate post-disciplinary hearing, the officer or officer's representative may present evidence and question witnesses.

     SECTION 5.  The hearing shall be conducted by an impartial hearing officer or body.  If the hearing is before the municipal governing body, the hearing may be conducted in an executive session, provided that final adjudication shall occur in an open session.

     SECTION 6.  This act shall not apply to a municipality that employs five (5) or fewer full-time sworn law enforcement officers.

     SECTION 7.  The rules of evidence and rules of discovery shall not apply to hearings held pursuant to this act.

     SECTION 8.  This act shall not apply to any municipality that has a civil service commission or that has an ordinance requiring a due process policy.

     SECTION 9.  This act shall take effect and be in force from and after January 1, 2008.


     Further, amend by striking the title in its entirety and inserting in lieu thereof the following:

 


     AN ACT TO REQUIRE MUNICIPALITIES TO PROVIDE A PRE-DISCIPLINARY HEARING PRIOR TO THE SUSPENSION OR TERMINATION OF ANY LAW ENFORCEMENT OFFICER; TO ESTABLISH A MINIMUM LEVEL OF WRITTEN DUE PROCESS PROCEDURES; TO SPECIFY WHAT NOTICE SHALL BE PROVIDED TO THE OFFICER; TO PROVIDE THAT THE OFFICER MAY ATTEND THE HEARING, MAY BE REPRESENTED BY COUNSEL, MAY PRESENT EVIDENCE ON HIS OWN BEHALF AND QUESTION WITNESSES; TO PROVIDE THAT THE EVIDENTIARY PHASE OF THE HEARING MAY BE HELD IN EXECUTIVE SESSION; TO PROVIDE THAT FINAL ADJUDICATION SHALL BE HELD IN OPEN MEETING; TO EXEMPT MUNICIPALITIES THAT HAVE A CIVIL SERVICE COMMISSION OR DUE PROCESS POLICY; AND FOR RELATED PURPOSES.


 

CONFEREES FOR THE SENATE          CONFEREES FOR THE HOUSE

 

 

X (SIGNED)

X (SIGNED)

Gray Tollison

Walter L. Robinson, Jr.

 

 

X (SIGNED)

X (SIGNED)

Johnnie E. Walls, Jr.

David W. Myers

 

 

X (SIGNED)

X (SIGNED)

J. Ed Morgan

John Mayo